When a court finds that an agreement is unenforceable and no recourse should be granted, the assets transferred under the agreement are at the place where they are transferred. There is no reversal of property rights. Illegality is not necessarily in the text of the treaty. This is the principle of public order; ex dolo malo non oritur actio. No court will assist a man who finds his complaint for an immoral or illegal act. If it appears to be the result of the applicant`s own reputation or in some other way the means ex turpi causa or the transgression of a positive law of this country, the court says there that he is not entitled to assistance. That is why the court is leaving; not for the defendant, but because they do not provide assistance to such a [plaintiff]. Therefore, if the [plaintiff] and the defendant changed sides and the defendant brought his action against the [plaintiff], the plaintiff would have the advantage; indeed, if both were equally responsible, potior is conditio defendentis [where both parties are wrong and where the plaintiff can succeed only on stolen property of an unlawful act, the defendant`s position is better] the purpose or purpose of the contract is to achieve an illegal purpose. The illicit objective may be known to one or both parties. An illegal provision of a contract may affect the entire contract. The Court of Appeal found that Parkingeye had no “firm intention” to act illegally and that illegality was incidental to the performance of the contract, but that it was far from at the heart of the contract. A contract creating a long-term relationship would be considered as a whole, so that, as in Parkingeye, it was possible to remove the illegality of future performance, the contract could remain in effect. On the other hand, there was less room for manoeuvre to correct a single contract, so it was more likely that it was not applicable.

A contract is considered illegal at the time of its creation if it is inoperative in the absence of an illegal act. Contracts in this category cannot be applied. Where a contract is illegal at the time of contract management, neither party acquires rights under this contract, regardless of whether or not the intent to break the law. The contract is null and private and is treated as if it had never been concluded. Parkingeye`s decision reiterates that a contract could be cancelled if it contains an element of illegality or if it was entered into with the intention of executing it illegally. It remains important that contracting parties enter into a contract ensure that no aspect of the treaty can be contrary to public policy or that it contains an element of illegality. The more serious or deliberate the illegality, the more the approach a court is likely to take to deny corrective action is tougher. The criminal courts are there to punish criminal behaviour on behalf of society: fines and penalties are imposed on behalf of society.

You may also like